Metal Shake vs Cedar Shakes in Barrie
Metal shake and natural cedar can both deliver a textured roof, but Barrie homeowners should compare weathering, fire considerations, moisture response, maintenance and appearance over time.
Quick comparison
Natural cedar is chosen for authentic material character and irregularity. Metal shake is often selected by homeowners who want a shake-inspired roof with lower moisture sensitivity and a factory-finished surface.
Metal shake-profile roofing
Metal shake forms wood-inspired grain and staggered shadow lines into coated steel. It is intended to provide a shake-like architectural character without relying on natural wood fibres.
- Factory-applied coatings provide the finished colour rather than natural weathering
- Interlocking edges can help manage wind and water when the complete system is installed correctly
- The roof does not split, rot or absorb moisture like wood
- Profile repetition, trim and colour choice influence the realism of the finished roof
Natural cedar shakes
Cedar shakes are split or sawn wood pieces with natural variation in thickness, grain and colour. Their character changes as they weather, and successful performance depends on material grade, ventilation, exposure and maintenance.
- Natural variation creates an appearance that manufactured products may only approximate
- Wood can absorb and release moisture as conditions change
- Moss, shade, debris and limited drying can accelerate deterioration
- Maintenance, treatment and replacement of individual shakes may be expected
What Barrie homeowners should compare
- Desired appearance when new and after years of weathering
- Shade, tree cover, drying conditions and roof ventilation
- Local fire-resistance expectations and product documentation
- Willingness to inspect, maintain and replace weathered pieces
Compare complete roof systems, not isolated features
A roofing decision includes the exterior product, deck preparation, underlayment, ventilation, fastening, flashing, perimeter details and workmanship. A material advantage can be lost when the selected profile does not suit the roof or when critical transitions are improvised.
Ask each contractor to identify the exact product and coating, explain how it will be installed on the building and provide the complete written warranty. Samples, technical documents and photographs of comparable completed roofs are more useful when reviewed together.
Consider future ownership
Initial price is only one part of cost. Homeowners should consider expected maintenance, repair access, availability of matching components, future alterations and the likelihood of another complete replacement. The most suitable choice is the one that fits the building, budget, appearance and ownership plan without relying on claims that cannot be verified in writing.
Frequently asked questions
Will metal shake develop the same patina as cedar?
No. Metal retains and ages through its coating system, while cedar changes naturally as the wood weathers.
Is cedar always noisier or quieter than metal?
Interior sound depends on the complete roof and attic assembly, not only the exterior material.
Can metal shake be used on cottages?
It can be considered for cottages and year-round homes when the profile, slope, deck and flashing requirements suit the building.
Compare Ontario metal-roofing options
Review roof profiles, finishes, installation methods and permanent roofing choices for your home.
This comparison is general education. Product instructions, testing, warranties, local requirements and the actual building conditions should control the final decision.
Contractor Member
50-Year Warranty